#eBooksForAll Frequently Asked Questions
Why has Macmillan Publishers decided to embargo eBooks sold to libraries?
Macmillan believes that every eBook checked out from a library is a lost sale and that eBook lending hurts the bottom line. In his memo announcing the embargo, Macmillan CEO John Sargent accused libraries of “cannibalizing” sales and actively “marketing… to turn purchasers in to borrowers.”
Do publishers and authors lose money by selling eBooks to libraries?
No. In fact, consumer sales for eBooks have levelled off while sales to libraries have increased. While there is no data to support Macmillan’s claim that increased eBook checkouts result in lost sales, there is data that shows that library borrowers are the same people who buy books .
Will an eight-week embargo increase individual eBook sales?
Making people wait an additional two months to borrow an eBook from a library will not necessarily increase consumer sales.
There are several reasons why people won’t immediately buy an eBook. Borrowers already wait a long time for eBooks they place on hold, even when hold lists number in the hundreds. Some will just go to another title on their long reading list. Some can’t afford to purchase hardcovers or eBooks, so they won’t buy them in any scenario.
While some library users may choose to buy an eBook to avoid an even longer holds queue, which could generate a few sales, Macmillan’s embargo guarantees they will lose library sales for eight weeks.
What value do libraries bring to eBook demand?
Libraries bring indisputable value in marketing books and cultivating readers – at no cost to publishers or authors. Every time a library displays a new title on its “new release” shelf, holds an author talk or book signing by a new writer, hosts book clubs or promotes a new title on social media, it provides free advertising that, cumulatively, is worth millions of dollars. This benefits readers, publishers and authors, especially newly published authors whose work would otherwise be difficult to discover. Libraries would be much less likely to market titles that are under embargo by a publisher.
If library patrons already wait for eBooks, why is an embargo such a bad thing?
Limiting access to new titles for libraries in any format means limiting readers’ access to information. Such an arbitrary embargo sets a dangerous precedent. Macmillan’s planned embargo now applies only to new titles, but what might they embargo next? The embargo is eight weeks now; how long might the next embargo delay access for library eBook borrowers? Macmillan’s policy is disconcerting because it could influence other publishers, most of whom currently support eBooks for all.
Who will specifically be affected by this embargo?
- All library eBook borrowers will be affected by longer waits on new titles published by Macmillan, and public libraries and their staff will bear the brunt of readers’ and patrons’ complaints.
- Library patrons with print disabilities such as dyslexia (or just poor eyesight) will have delayed access to a digital format that offers adjustable text size and spacing.
- Library patrons with certain physical disabilities will lack access to eBooks on portable devices that are lighter and easier to hold.
Do any other publishers embargo sales to libraries?
Macmillan Publishers is the only one of the “Big Five” publishers (Hachette Book Group, HarperCollins, Macmillan, Penguin Random House and Simon & Schuster) to announce an embargo on new eBook sales to libraries. However, ALA is concerned that other publishers may follow suit and institute embargos of their own on eBook sales to libraries, which already pay top dollar for eBooks.
How much do libraries pay for eBooks?
Publishers have various business models for eBook lending, but all charge libraries more for an eBook than a consumer pays — often up to five times the retail price of an eBook. Libraries purchase enough copies of an eBook title to meet the demand they anticipate at their library as their budget permits.
However, publishers do not sell eBooks to libraries; they lease a copy of an eBook title to a library for a contracted amount of time (commonly two years). Once the license is up, the library loses access to the content and must repurchase the eBook at the same high price.
eBook licensing terms for Big Five Publishers
eBook license term for libraries
Two-year licensing model
Metered licensing model (26 check-outs)
A perpetual license for one copy of a new title.
Additional metered licenses available after an eight-week embargo (two years)
Penguin Random House
Two-year licensing model
Simon & Schuster
Two-year licensing model
What do libraries want?
Libraries want to fulfill their mission: to ensure that all people have access to the world's knowledge through our nation's libraries, regardless of format. Access to eBooks for libraries should neither be denied nor delayed by anyone. Period.
Is there room for libraries and publishers to negotiate terms of sale for eBooks?
Yes. The American Library Association and other leaders within the library community have held discussions with publishers since 2012. As ALA Executive Director Mary Ghikas told reporters at the press conference announcing ALA’s eBooksForAll petition, “An embargo is not a good way to start a conversation.”
What are libraries doing to oppose the embargo?
- Library professionals across the country have sent individual letters to Macmillan CEO John Sargent objecting to the embargo.
- State and national library associations have made public statements denouncing Macmillan’s embargo.
- Advocates for #eBooksForAll in libraries have written letters to the editor, like this one by King County Library System Director Lisa Rosenblum that ran in the Wall Street Journal.
- Library leaders are working with members of Congress (such as Congresswoman Pramila Jayapal (PDF)) and the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on the Judiciary Subcommittee on Antitrust, Commercial and Administrative Law to explore the issue and identify potential legislative solutions.
- Thousands are showing support for #eBooksForAll in libraries on social media.
- Now, libraries are encouraging their patrons to sign the #eBooksForAll petition to cancel the embargo.